For Sale USA

Pencil toppers

4

Pencil toppers for sale on largest auction and classifieds sites

Home / / Pencil toppers refurbished & used for sale | For Sale USA
Vintage monster pencil toppers - pencil,

Vintage monster pencil toppers - pencil,

$24.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage novelty pencil - vintage,

Vintage novelty pencil - vintage,

$139.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
18pcs pencil top - pencil, erasers

18pcs pencil top - pencil, erasers

$22.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Random lot 50pcs ooshies - 50pcs,

Random lot 50pcs ooshies - 50pcs,

$31.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy rubber - retro,

Vintage retro squishy rubber - retro,

$4.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy - vintage/, rubbe

Vintage retro squishy - vintage/, rubbe

$4.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot vintage applause russ - applause,

Lot vintage applause russ - applause,

$99.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Angry birds pencil toppers - pencil,

Angry birds pencil toppers - pencil,

$20.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
24pcs halloween pencils - 24pcs, with

24pcs halloween pencils - 24pcs, with

$13.98
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy - retro,

Vintage retro squishy - retro,

$4.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1991 barbie - barbie, applause

Vintage 1991 barbie - barbie, applause

$2.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot gummi bear pencil - 4,

Lot gummi bear pencil - 4,

$13.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1990 cabbage patch - vintage,

Vintage 1990 cabbage patch - vintage,

$15.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
18pcs pencil top erasers - pencil, for

18pcs pencil top erasers - pencil, for

$22.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Kachooz moops pencil toppers - moops, 4

Kachooz moops pencil toppers - moops, 4

$12.49
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
18pcs pencil top erasers - top,

18pcs pencil top erasers - top,

$22.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Skull pencil topper - topper, eraser

Skull pencil topper - topper, eraser

$11.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Street fighter vintage - street, rare

Street fighter vintage - street, rare

$4.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Glow count chocula - chocula, franken

Glow count chocula - chocula, franken

$12.50
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage comics 1970 s - dc,

Vintage comics 1970 s - dc,

$39.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy rubber - vintage/,

Vintage retro squishy rubber - vintage/,

$4.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Erasers for pencils - erasers, 120

Erasers for pencils - erasers, 120

$10.64
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Frito lay vintage pencil - vintage,

Frito lay vintage pencil - vintage,

$30.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot garfield rubber - of, 2

Lot garfield rubber - of, 2

$7.53
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Novelty bear topper pencils

Novelty bear topper pencils

$8.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Easter novelty vintage - , topper

Easter novelty vintage - , topper

$16.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot vintage 80s - of,

Lot vintage 80s - of,

$18.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1970s comics - vintage,

Vintage 1970s comics - vintage,

$14.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg kelloggs 1987 - vtg,

Vtg kelloggs 1987 - vtg,

$22.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Pencil toppers for - pencil,

Pencil toppers for - pencil,

$11.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Pcs cute pencil topper - cute,

Pcs cute pencil topper - cute,

$15.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg rubber pencil topper - pencil, head

Vtg rubber pencil topper - pencil, head

$17.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage garfield pencil topper - pencil,

Vintage garfield pencil topper - pencil,

$4.43
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Mushroom figures pencil - mushroom,

Mushroom figures pencil - mushroom,

$11.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Garfield figures lot of 5 - figures,

Garfield figures lot of 5 - figures,

$19.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1980s russ happy - 1980s,

Vintage 1980s russ happy - 1980s,

$11.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Garfield and odie pencil - odie,

Garfield and odie pencil - odie,

$5.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg garfield kellogg cereal - vtg,

Vtg garfield kellogg cereal - vtg,

$12.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage collectible pencils - collectible,

Vintage collectible pencils - collectible,

$60.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
100pcs pencil toppers - 100pcs,

100pcs pencil toppers - 100pcs,

$22.12
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lisa frank halloween - lisa, pencils

Lisa frank halloween - lisa, pencils

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Monster cereal pencil - monster,

Monster cereal pencil - monster,

$16.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Colorful penguin figures - penguin,

Colorful penguin figures - penguin,

$10.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot vintage troll doll - lot,

Lot vintage troll doll - lot,

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Skull pencil toppers - skull,

Skull pencil toppers - skull,

$3.49
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy large - vintage/,

Vintage retro squishy large - vintage/,

$8.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot rubber pencil topper - of, 26

Lot rubber pencil topper - of, 26

$19.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage novelty pencil toppers - vintage,

Vintage novelty pencil toppers - vintage,

$9.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Gray koala bear claw - gray,

Gray koala bear claw - gray,

$12.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1993 diener ind turkey - vintage,

Vintage 1993 diener ind turkey - vintage,

$4.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage collectible pencils - collectible,

Vintage collectible pencils - collectible,

$44.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage pencil toppers lot - vintage,

Vintage pencil toppers lot - vintage,

$9.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Shopkins eraser pencil - eraser,

Shopkins eraser pencil - eraser,

$26.97
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage troll halloween - vintage, pencil

Vintage troll halloween - vintage, pencil

$16.36
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Wwe wrestling pencil toppers - wwe,

Wwe wrestling pencil toppers - wwe,

$18.19
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Kachooz moops pencil toppers - kachooz,

Kachooz moops pencil toppers - kachooz,

$3.50
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Gremlins pencil toppers 1990 - gremlins, 2

Gremlins pencil toppers 1990 - gremlins, 2

$4.50
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Mixed lot vintage - ,

Mixed lot vintage - ,

$17.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg pencil lot y2k lisa - vtg, frank

Vtg pencil lot y2k lisa - vtg, frank

$33.96
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Random 50pcs ooshies pencil - random,

Random 50pcs ooshies pencil - random,

$28.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy - vintage/, rubber

Vintage retro squishy - vintage/, rubber

$6.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Super rare 1966 - diener, batman

Super rare 1966 - diener, batman

$625.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Pokemon pencil toppers - pokemon, lot

Pokemon pencil toppers - pokemon, lot

$30.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage frustration fuzzy - 2, (fuzzy

Vintage frustration fuzzy - 2, (fuzzy

$9.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage nyc pencil - pencil, &

Vintage nyc pencil - pencil, &

$25.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot collectible pencil - lot, 14

Lot collectible pencil - lot, 14

$4.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg 1970 walt disney hard - walt,

Vtg 1970 walt disney hard - walt,

$15.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
100 vintage diener halloween - 100,

100 vintage diener halloween - 100,

$33.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot erasers and - lot, of

Lot erasers and - lot, of

$3.26
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy rubber - retro,

Vintage retro squishy rubber - retro,

$4.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage godzilla monsters - vintage,

Vintage godzilla monsters - vintage,

$28.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1987 diener - vintage, witch

Vintage 1987 diener - vintage, witch

$28.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Odie rubber pencil toppers - odie,

Odie rubber pencil toppers - odie,

$2.49
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage russ novelty - 14,

Vintage russ novelty - 14,

$28.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg plush clip - clip, hugger

Vtg plush clip - clip, hugger

$39.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg 80s 90s novelty pen - vtg, pencil

Vtg 80s 90s novelty pen - vtg, pencil

$37.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Comics ooshies pencil - dc,

Comics ooshies pencil - dc,

$6.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 1960s scandia house - vintage,

Vintage 1960s scandia house - vintage,

$24.98
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage 90s character - vintage,

Vintage 90s character - vintage,

$44.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Sqwishland squishy pencil - sqwishland,

Sqwishland squishy pencil - sqwishland,

$12.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Eraser pencil topper - eraser/pencil,

Eraser pencil topper - eraser/pencil,

$5.20
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage troll dolls lot - vintage,

Vintage troll dolls lot - vintage,

$19.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot mini small troll - 11,

Lot mini small troll - 11,

$12.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Hamtaro orange white hamster - hamtaro,

Hamtaro orange white hamster - hamtaro,

$19.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage retro squishy rubber - squishy,

Vintage retro squishy rubber - squishy,

$4.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Huge lot marvel - marvel, squishy

Huge lot marvel - marvel, squishy

$24.44
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vtg 1970s plastic - vtg, owl

Vtg 1970s plastic - vtg, owl

$6.67
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Lot tmnt pencil - of, eraser

Lot tmnt pencil - of, eraser

$13.49
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage pencil topper - topper, turtle

Vintage pencil topper - topper, turtle

$10.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Pencil topper top advertising - topper,

Pencil topper top advertising - topper,

$15.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Wbei silver harry potter - silver,

Wbei silver harry potter - silver,

$3.58
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Tmnt ooshies teenage - teenage, mutant

Tmnt ooshies teenage - teenage, mutant

$12.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Disney pencil with character - pencil,

Disney pencil with character - pencil,

$7.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Vintage mcdonald pencil - mcdonald's,

Vintage mcdonald pencil - mcdonald's,

$18.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Fun multi point - fun, multi-point

Fun multi point - fun, multi-point

$32.97
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Garfield odie pencil topper - garfield,

Garfield odie pencil topper - garfield,

$33.48
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored

Looking for more pencil toppers?

Search eBay live — fresh results filtered for the best value, updated every hour.

🔍 Search live deals
📊96 listings · from $2 · avg $25.49

Browse 96 pencil toppers listings currently in our index. Prices range from $2 to $625, with an average of $25.49. Whether you are hunting for a bargain or looking for a top-spec model, the selection below covers all price points — new, used and refurbished. More about pencil toppers →

Try this: jennifer aniston | baguio | rosenthal teapot | casio calculator | brandy | rotor chainrings | bonito | cognex | detector | trojan

Shop by budget

< $25 $25 – $50 $50 – $100 $100 – $200 $200 – $500 > $500

Everything you need to know about pencil toppers

Whether you are looking for a brand-new or second-hand pencil toppers, eBay offers one of the largest selections available online. With 96 active listings at the time of this page's last update, you have plenty of choice across different conditions, sellers and price points. The cheapest option currently starts at $2, while premium listings can reach $625 — giving you a wide budget spread to work with. The average price of $25.49 can serve as a useful benchmark: listings below this tend to be used or auction-style, while those above often include extra accessories, warranties, or are sold by professional sellers with high feedback scores. Always check the seller's feedback rating and return policy before committing to a purchase. If you need the item quickly, filter by "Buy It Now" to avoid the uncertainty of auctions. For used items, look closely at the condition description and photos — terms like "good", "very good" and "like new" can mean very different things depending on the seller.

🔍 pencil toppers Search live on eBay